| |
 |
|
Burgess and Stephens
alternate design for Ranger, 1936
Drawing: ©2004
CupInfo
|
Genesis:
The J-Class was adopted for America's Cup competition
in 1928, looking forward to the next regatta in 1930. The Class itself,
though, dated back to the turn of the century when the Universal Rule was
adopted.
The Rule used a yacht's various dimensions to
calculate an equivalent rating in feet. Boats of equal rated lengths
could then race against each other directly without making other
allowances for time or distance sailed. Even though one yacht might
have a longer length or another yacht a larger sail area, their overall
configurations had to produce a rated length that met the Universal
Rule for that class. J-Class yachts were the largest constructed under
the Universal Rule. The Rule actually includes provisions for an even
larger type of boat, the I-Class, though none were ever built.
Inquiries made in the 1930s for a Defense in the smaller K-Class were
rejected.
The J-Class were the first yachts in an
America's Cup match to be governed by a formal design rule. Previous
defenders and challengers were only restricted by minimum and maximum
lengths set forth in the Deed of Gift. Sir Thomas Lipton,
challenging in 1930 for the fifth time, had held earlier discussions with
the New York Yacht Club in hopes of adopting the Universal Rule for the
previous America's Cup match, intended for 1914 but delayed until 1920.
Though an agreement to use the rule was not reached for that match, the
1914 boats, Vanitie and Resolute, still roughly followed
J-Class parameters.
Building Program:
There were only 10 J-class yachts designed and built.
Additionally, several yachts of closely related dimensions, mostly 23-Meter
International Rule boats, were converted after
their construction to meet the
rating rules of the J-Class.
Only the purpose-built Cup yachts, though, could
compete in the America's Cup. The "converted" J-Class yachts, while
acceptable for Class racing events, were not admissible for America's Cup
competition. Responding to issues that surfaced in earlier defenses,
the America's Cup rules required that all boats had to be sailed to the event on their
own bottom. Some critics pointed out the possibility that the
challenger might, as a result, be disadvantaged by being of heavier
construction than the defender. In order to avoid a
situation that could be perceived as an undue advantage, the NYYC
eventually agreed that all America's Cup J-Class yachts would be built to
Lloyds A1 standards, ensuring that defender and challenger met the same
minimum construction specifications (the nautical term is "scantlings"). Most existing yachts were not built to such standards,
so the Cup-eligible boats thus ended up heavier than the
ineligible J's.
(The issue of challengers having to build
heavier boats due to the ocean crossing was a popular, if uncertain,
explanation in the British press for the long string of American
victories. In practice, a number of challengers added internal
bracing for the crossing, which was then removed before racing. And on a few occasions
defenders subsequently made the crossing in reverse in search of
competition following their successful defense. The rule requiring
that the challenger sail to the event on her own bottom was
actually instituted in response to a super-lightweight challenger towed
to the match through canals and rivers from Canada. )
The J-Class Yachts
|
Name |
|
|
Built |
Owner |
Designer |
Builder |
AC Role |
LWL |
LOA |
Disp. (tons) |
SA |
Disposition |
|
Enterprise |
US |
|
1930 |
Aldrich Syndicate |
W. Starling Burgess |
Herreshoff Mfg. Co. |
1930 Defender |
80 |
120 |
128 |
7583 |
scrapped 1935 |
|
Whirlwind |
US |
|
1930 |
Whirlwind Syndicate |
L. Francis Herreshoff |
George Lawley and Son,
Boston |
|
86 |
130 |
|
7335 |
scrapped 1935 |
|
Yankee |
US |
|
1930 |
Yankee Syndicate |
Frank Paine |
George Lawley and Son,
Boston |
|
84 |
126 |
148 |
7288 |
scrapped 1941 |
|
Weetamoe |
US |
|
1930 |
Morgan syndicate |
Clinton Crane |
Herreshoff Mfg. Co. |
|
83 |
125.5 |
|
7550 |
scrapped 1937 |
|
Rainbow |
US |
|
1934 |
Harold S. "Mike" Vanderbilt |
W. Starling Burgess |
Herreshoff Mfg. Co. |
1934 Defender |
82 |
127.7 |
141 |
7535 |
scrapped 1940 |
|
Ranger |
US |
|
1937 |
Harold S. "Mike" Vanderbilt |
W. Starling Burgess and Olin
Stephens II |
Bath Iron Works |
1937 Defender |
87 |
135.5 |
166 |
7546 |
laid-up 1937; scrapped 1941 |
| |
|
|
|
|
|
|
|
|
|
|
|
|
|
Shamrock V |
UK |
J K3 |
1930 |
Sir Thomas Lipton |
Charles Nicholson |
Camper & Nicholson |
1930 Challenger |
81.1 |
119.8 |
134 |
7540 |
restored. |
|
Endeavour |
UK |
J K4 |
1934 |
T.O.M. Sopwith |
Charles Nicholson |
Camper & Nicholson |
1934 Challenger |
83.3 |
129.8 |
143 |
7561 |
restored |
|
Endeavour II |
UK |
J K6 |
1936 |
T.O.M. Sopwith |
Charles Nicholson |
Camper & Nicholson |
1937 Challenger |
87 |
135.8 |
162 |
7543 |
laid-up 1938 |
|
Velsheda |
|
J K7 |
1932 |
W.L. Stephenson (US) |
Charles Nicholson |
Camper & Nicholson |
|
83 |
|
|
|
survives |
| |
|
|
|
|
|
|
|
|
|
|
|
|
|
Other Yachts |
|
|
|
|
|
|
|
|
|
|
|
|
|
Vanitie |
US |
|
1914 |
|
William Gardner |
|
|
|
|
|
|
scrapped 1938 |
|
Resolute |
US |
|
1914 |
|
Nathanial G. Herreshoff |
|
1920 Defender |
74'11" |
106'4" |
|
8775 |
scrapped 1939 |
|
White Heather II |
UK |
|
1907 |
W.L. Stephenson (US) |
Fife |
|
|
|
|
|
|
|
| |
|
|
|
|
|
|
|
|
|
|
|
|
|
23M yachts |
|
|
|
|
|
|
|
|
|
|
|
|
|
Cambria |
UK |
K4 |
1927 |
Sir William Berry |
William Fife III |
|
|
80 |
135 |
|
|
survives |
|
Astra |
UK |
K2 |
1928 |
Sir Mortimer Singer |
Charles E. Nicholson |
Camper & Nicholson |
|
|
|
|
|
survives |
|
Candida |
UK |
K8 |
1932 |
Hermann Andreae |
Charles E. Nicholson |
Camper & Nicholson |
|
|
|
|
|
survives |
| |
|
|
|
|
|
|
|
|
|
|
|
|
|
Britannia |
UK |
K1 |
1893 |
HRH Prince of Wales |
George L. Watson |
Henderson's on Clyde |
|
87'10" |
148'0" |
|
10,317 |
stripped and scuttled 1936
|
| |
|
|
|
|
|
|
|
|
|
|
|
|
| |
|
|
|
|
|
|
|
|
|
|
|
|
Notes:
|
Enterprise |
Launched April 14, 1930. Pioneered "Park Avenue" boom design.
Spruce original mast replaced by circular section double-skin duralumin mast
built by Glenn L. Martin Co, May, 1930. Tobin bronze plating.
Triple-headed rig. Trialed with retracting spreaders.
Adversely affected by rule changes for 1934 requiring full
accommodations for crew and winches located above decks.
Aldrich Syndicate: Harold Vanderbilt, Vincent Astor, George Baker,
George Whitney, Floyd Carlisle, E. Walter Clarke.
|
|
|
Whirlwind |
Launched May 7, 1930. Name: "Whirlwind" was
also the name of a clipper ship owned by syndicate member Landon
Thorne's family. Double-ended, inspired by Herreshoff's M-Class
Istalena. Mahogany planking over steel frames. Pine
deck. Spruce
original mast replaced with duralumin. Led J's with double-headsail rig.
Electric wind-speed devices. Sold to Pynchon. Whirlwind Syndicate: Landon Thorne, Alfred
Loomis, Paul Hammond. Longest J-Class until
1937.
|
|
|
Yankee |
Launched May 10, 1930. Yankee Syndicate: John Lawrence, Charles Francis
Adams, Chandler Hovey. Spruce original mast. Tobin bronze
plating. Triple-headed rig. Defense Trials, 1934,
modified entry/slightly longer waterline.
Sold to Gerald Lambert, 1935. Sailed to England, 1935 (only US
J to do so).
Raced in England. Sold for scrap by Lambert (reportedly for $10,000) in
April, 1941, Fall River, MA, with proceeds donated to war effort.
Tender: Utility
|
|
|
Weetamoe |
Launched May 10, 1930. Name: "Weetamoe" was an American Indian Queen;
Tobin bronze plating. Triple-headed rig. Morgan Syndicate: George Nichols, J.P.Morgan, Cornelius Vanderbilt,
Arthur Curtiss James, George T. Bowdoin, Henry Walters, Gerald
Lambert. Cost estimated at $300,000 for hulls, rig, and sails. Narrowest of the four 1930 US boats.
Sold to Fredrick Henry Prince, October, 1930. Hull modified for 1934,
including larger and heavier keel; believed to be slower, later restored to
original configuration. Weetamoe also raced in the off-years between defenses. 1930 Tender:
Emblane.
|
|
|
Rainbow |
Last Herreshoff-built America's Cup boat.
Duralumin mast
built by Glenn L. Martin Co. Adopted bending boom design. Bar
rigging. Scrapped August, 1940, Fall River, MA. Reportedly
brought $12,000.
|
|
|
Ranger |
Design based on Burgess's scheme derived from
models tested in Stevens Institute towing-tank during partnership
work with Olin Stephens; final design has elements of both men's
ideas; design lines established by August, 1936; keel laid December,
1936; cost $500,000; steel hull, flush riveted;
heat-treated steel rod shrouds; translucent bakelite deck inserts;
lost mast on delivery cruise off Cape Cod; replaced with new in 21 days; used
wheel, rigging and sails salvaged from Rainbow and Enterprise (same No.
1 main was used on all three); Vanderbilt's 3 J's all used the
tender Bystander, which also served the 12M defender
candidate Vim in 1958, and challengers Gretel (1962)
and Dame Pattie (1967); Launched May 11, 1937; Bath
Iron Works Hull # 172; built at cost; funded solely by Vanderbilt;
named for US frigate Ranger commanded by
John Paul Jones; largest displacement J-Class; Hauled at end
of 1937 and never sailed again. Sold for scrap May, 1941,
bringing $12,000.
|
|
|
Shamrock V |
Built at Camper & Nicholson yard in Gosport.
Mahogany planking over steel frames, yellow
pine deck; teak stem, stern posts, and counter-timbers; hollow spruce mast, elliptical
section; lower sail area but greater rig height relative to other
J's; Extensively tuned up in England before 1930 Challenge; Sold to Sopwith 1932; modified by Sopwith including hull
and rudder; Sold
to Sir Richard Fairey; Sold to Mario Crespi post-war; Sold to Piero
Scanu 1962; renamed Quattrofoglio (spelling uncertain but roughly
"Four Leaf" in Italian as a play on her original name); ketch-rigged?; Appeared in movie
"Swept Away"; Rebuilt at C&N 1967-70; Sold to Lipton Tea Co.
1986, donated
to Newport Museum of Yachting; Restored under Elizabeth Meyer 1989, rig,
bulwarks, deckhouse rebuilt to original; sold to Newport Yacht
Restoration School 1995; sold to Newport Shamrock V
Corp 1998; refit 2000 at Pendennis, under Gerard Dykstra; sold to Marcos de Maraes, Brazil.
Lipton had a 23M yacht also named Shamrock, sometimes
confused with his America's Cup boats. The 23M was broken up
in 1933.
|
|
|
Endeavour |
Steel hull, Steel mast, originally "North Circular"
bending boom, later "Park Avenue" boom; Originated use of double-clewed
"quadrilateral" jib; Sold to Herman Andrae; Chartered to Sopwith for
1936; Broke loose from tow mid-ocean returning to England, September
1937; Laid up 1937 Camper & Nicholson; Sold for scrap 1947 to
Charles Kerridge Limited, intent to scrap keel for lead content, but
hull reprieved; sat as abandoned hulk for decades; sold for 10
pounds in 1970's; restoration started; sold to Elizabeth Meyer 1984;
restored by Meyer, with Gerard Dykstra as designer, work completed
at Royal Huisman and re-launched in 1989;
sold to Dennis Kozlowski (2000), yacht based in Newport, RI; sold to Cassio
Antunes (2006) for reported $13.1 million USD, apparent plan to base
in Cayman Islands and Cascais, Portugal.
|
|
|
Endeavour II |
Launched June 8, 1936.
Greatest LOA, tallest rig (158 ft. from deck). Flush-plated
steel hull. Steel framing, planking, mast, wood Park Avenue boom.
Steel centerboard. Pine decks. Launched and trialed in
1936 for 1937 challenge. Twice dismasted in 1936 trials. Laid
up 1937 Camper & Nicholson; Sold for scrap 1947 to Charles Kerridge
Limited, intent to scrap keel for lead content. Hulk remains
to be broken up in 1968.
|
|
|
Velsheda |
Only J-boat not designed to compete in America's
Cup; Steel mast; reused material from smelting White Heather II's keel;
Ends modified 1935; Name
combines Stephenson's daughters Velma, Daphne, and Sheila; (laid up
25 years?); Restored Terry Brabant 1983, maintaining very original
condition; Sailed as charter; Sold to Swiss owner, refit
stalled for lack of funds; Laid up Gosport; Sold in 1996, major refit 1996-7
at Southhampton Yacht Services under Gerard Dykstra, interior, CF rig, sails, modernized, but
less authentic; Current owner Ronald de Waal. |
|
| |
|
|
|
Vanitie |
A 1920 Defender
Candidate, Vanitie lost to Resolute in 1914 trials (defense
postponed) and 1920 trials, losing 7-4 in final 1920 selection
series. Owned by Alexander Smith Cochran. Not designed as a J, but altered after construction
to rate as a J; not acceptable for AC as a J-Class yacht because lightweight, not
Lloyd's A1. Sold to Gerald Lambert, 1928. Trial horse 1930 and 1934 America's
Cup defender trials. Laid-up at Herreshoff Mfg. and scrapped there
in 1938.
|
|
|
Resolute |
Converted to schooner
rig in the 1920s; Not designed as a J, but altered after
construction to rate as a J; not acceptable for AC as a J-Class
yacht because lightweight, not Lloyd's A1. Sold to E. Walter
Clarke. Laid-up at Herreshoff Mfg. and scrapped there in 1939.
Beam 21'11", draft 13'9".
|
|
| |
|
|
|
White Heather II |
Converted to J rating in 1930. Established
Nicholson's reputation in big racing
yachts.
|
|
|
Cambria |
Cambria shares name with First Challenger to
a US Defender, 1870; Sold to Mike Sears (US, McDonnell-Douglas) 1972; Sold to
Charlie Whitcombe (NZ) 1987; Sold to AUS restoration Group (Denis
O'Neil, John David, Ian Murray) 1994; refit `99?; for sale 2000
($7.5 M); rated as a J-Class, 2003, though she was not rated as such
in the 1920s and 30s.
|
|
|
Astra |
Not designed as a J, but altered after construction
to rate as a J in 1931; raced well as J in light weather; Sold to
Sir Howard Frank; sold to Hugh Paul,
1930; sold to Italian ownership 1950, converted to Yawl rig; Gian
Carlo Bussei led restoration 1987 at Cantieri Navali Becooncini, La
Spezia, Italy.
|
|
|
Candida |
Sailed poorly under J rating, converted to yawl
Norlanda by
Nicholson for Italian Owner; restored 1989.
|
|
|
Britannia |
Launched April 20, 1893; Defeated America's Cup
Defender Vigilant in fleet racing on the Clyde, 1894; Built
for HRH Albert Edward, Prince of Wales; Sold to
private owners, 1897; Bought back in 1902, after the Prince
had acceded to the throne as Edward VII; Passed to his son George V after Edward's death
in 1910; Rated after construction as 23M; not designed as a J, but altered in 1931, converted to
"Marconi" rig, sail area 8,700 sf, triple-headed, and rated as a J; modified
to double-headed-rig and Park Avenue boom in 1935; Scuttled off the Isle of Wight by
Edward VIII, July 9, 1936, as per wishes of his father, George V,
who did not wish to see the yacht live on to a life of decline once
he was gone.
|
|
| |
|
|
Disposition:
Conceived at the height of the affluent 1920's, the
J-boats arrived during the Great Depression. They required enormous
crews, and, despite expert attention to their technical details, still
broke an astonishing number of masts. While they were in
most regards the most advanced sailing yachts yet built, and they were indeed powerful
sailing thoroughbreds formed in sleek lines that can race the pulse of
almost every viewer, the glorious J's proved too
extravagant for their own good. Most had very limited sailing careers
outside of America's Cup. Ranger, whose 1937 cost was upwards
of $500,000, was laid-up at the end of her debut season and never sailed
again. All of the American J's were scrapped between 1935 and 1941. Most
of the British J's were either abandoned or scrapped.
When NYYC sought to revive the America's Cup in the
1950s, there was a faction that favored returning to the J-Class.
Mike Vanderbilt even stated that not only would he like to see the Cup
contested in the large boats, but that if so he would consider rebuilding
a new Ranger to the design of the original. Still, another faction
hoped for smaller dual-use yachts that could be used in offshore racing
when the Cup year was ended. With cost estimates for a 1958-era J
starting around three million dollars, the impulse for a J-Class defense faded
away in the face of economic pressures and a compromise was reached to
sail the America's Cup in International Rule 12-Meters.
 |
|
Endeavour in Newport, 2004
Photo
©2004
CupInfo |
|
Out of nine America's
Cup J's, only two survive today: Shamrock V, the 1930 Challenger,
and Endeavour, the 1934 Challenger. Velsheda,
distinguished by being the only yacht built as a J-class though not
intended for America's Cup, is intact and sailing, too. Of at least seven other
boats that were rated as J's, two remain: Cambria, and Astra.
Cambria was originally a
23-Meter International Rule yacht, but later altered to rate as a J. The surviving
boats have all had extensive restoration and re-building. Endeavour
was rescued from near oblivion, too delicate to move without structural
reconstruction.
J-Class rigs today are no longer built of wood or dur-alumin, but
with modern lightweight composites. Their sail technology is
long past being canvas duck, and many other subtle changes have been made to make the
ongoing maintenance and operation of these yachts a realistic proposition.
Still, the J-Class owners have gone to great lengths to insure the
integrity of the boats. The J-Class is self-administered, rather
than governed by an outside organization as is the case with almost all
other classes. This allows the members to more easily adapt the rules
in order to serve the needs of the uniquely historic yachts.
Most of the surviving J's are
available for charter. Cambria was reportedly for sale in
2000. Endeavour changed hands in 2006 for a reported $13.1
million USD, though as her former owner Dennis Kozlowski said, "No one
truly owns Endeavour. She's a part of yachting history.''
Recreations, Replicas, and a
Tender:
For decades, most
yachting fans thought that we would never again see the likes of these
boats again, the few survivors would sooner or later fade away, and the
whole history would be reserved for books and fading photographs, but following the
restoration of the surviving hulls rumors grew throughout the late 1990's
and early 2000's about building "new" J's. In 2001, all of this dock talk began to become reality:
Ranger
Wooden Boat magazine, March/April 2001, described a
"Dutchman" who had commissioned a new Ranger built to the
original's plan. This incredible rumor came true, and a piece of
lost sailing history was brought back to life. The new version of this "superboat",
as Mike Vanderbilt once called her, was officially launched in October,
2004.
Designed by Studio Scanu and Reichel-Pugh, and built by Danish
Yachts, Skagen, Denmark, she is not an exact replica of the original. Some would term her a
re-interpretation, as a number of changes were made including greater
freeboard, and Ranger's original designers did not participate in
the project. The new Ranger first competed head-to-head
against other J's in Antigua, Spring, 2004. It took some additional
adjustment after launch by her owners and
designers to seek the proper trim that would make her float on
her lines, an essential step in the process of being officially rated a
J-Class yacht. Visit the
Ranger Website for more info.
J-Class
Management is also at work on a restoration of Bystander, tender to the
original Ranger.
Endeavour II
An Endeavour II replica is being built at Royal Huisman Shipyard,
with a planned 2008 launch date.
Gerard Dykstra and Partners is leading the project, which features
a lightweight Alustar (aluminum alloy) hull and carbon-fiber mast. See
additional photo at
Yachtspotter
 |
|
Drawing:
©2008 Dykstra & Partners
New J-Class Yacht Rainbow
(click image to view
large pdf) |
|
| |
|
Lionheart
Based on an unbuilt alternate design by Starling Burgess and Olin Stephens
II that was considered for 1937's America's Cup defender Ranger,
this new boat is being built at yards in the Netherlands for an expected
2008 launch. Lionheart will be the longest J-Class yacht when completed.
See more including photos of the completed hull at the
Lionheart
Website
Designer:
Hoek Design
Builders: Bloemsma
Aluminiumbouw and
Claasen Jachtbouw BV
Svea
Tore Holm's unbuilt 1937 design, said by some to be faster in the test
tank than any of the original boats, is being pursued by
Hoek Design
Name To Be Announced
In late March 2008, reports of another replica about to begin
construction appeared on the
Classic Boat website. Whether this is one of the known
projects, such as Svea, above, or yet another replica about to
become reality, such as Rainbow, below, should become known shortly.
Rainbow
In late May, 2008, Dykstra and
Partners announced that a new build of the 1934 America's Cup Defender
Rainbow was underway, with an expected launch date of 2010.
Read the Press Release
Other projects:
Hoek Design is also studying replicas of 1930's Enterprise and
another boat from Yankee designer Frank Paine. Yankee
herself has also been rumored as a new project, as well. Earlier
reports of a Ranger alternate carrying the name of Seawolf
may have been referring to the project that has become Lionheart,
see above. Whirlwind and Weetamoe are the only two
designs of the original ten J's that aren't known to be sailing, building,
or under serious consideration as of 2008. The J-Class
website points out that there are 10 unbuilt J designs from the 1930's, so
the possibilities for more J-Class yachts are intriguing.
Yachting World reported
in
May, 2003, that construction was underway on
a yacht replicating the famous G.L Watson design Britannia.
Photos showed a nearly completed hull at Solombala Shipyard, in Arkhangel,
Russia, and included interviews with the yacht's owner Sigurd Coates of
Norway. The design was adapted by Cesil Stephansen from published
plans. The original designer's modern descendent company, G.L.Watson & Co., Ltd., has no involvement with
the Arkhangel project. Puzzlingly, little has been heard of this ambitious
project since.
In the Spirit
A similar project to return elegant yachts to
competitive racing, the W-class, was set in motion by Donald Tofias, an
American enthusiast. He commissioned naval architect Joel White to design a new class
with lines evocative of famous racing yachts like the New York 50's and
the J-Class. The first two boats, Wild Horses and White Wings,
were built in Maine of modern cold-molded wood construction and launched
in 1998. It is Tofias' aim that there will eventually be a whole fleet of
the beautiful W-class to regularly compete against each other. The
one-design W-76 is actually similar to the New York 50's. Tofias'
long-range plans involve a range of classes including 46, 62, 76, 105, and
130. The 130's would be nearly identical in basic dimensions to the
J-class. See the
W-Class
Website.
Web Sites of Particular
Interest:
The J-Class
Association
J-Class
Management, Inc.
Further Notes:
K-Class:
The Royal
London Yacht Club made and withdrew its inquiry for a K-Class challenge
in 1935. The intent had been to reduce costs, not the least of which
was hoped to be a slower velocity of mast replacements, but the K-Class line
of thought was rejected for several reasons. For one, the K-Class
wasn't so much smaller than the J-Class as to have clearly led to
significant savings. Additionally, no K-Class yachts existed on
either side of the Atlantic while several J's of various pedigree were
available for testing, training, and racing in 1935. Also a factor
was that the NYYC was already actively considering another challenge at the time
the RLYC began their communication about the K-Class and it was the NYYC's policy to
consider only one challenge at a time, in keeping with the Deed of Gift.
Sailing to the Event on Own Bottom:
This provision of the Deed of Gift was strictly interpreted to the the degree of making sure that the challenging yacht
actually was under her own sail while traveling to the match, not towed by another yacht.
Challengers returning across the Atlantic after Cup matches concluded were
sometimes towed for convenience.
|
|